Professor and Director of the Medical Ethics Program at the University of Wisconsin
Position:
Pro to the question "Should performance enhancing drugs (such as steroids) be accepted in sports?"
Reasoning:
"Nearly everyone condemns the use of drugs - amphetamines, cocaine, steroids, and narcotics, in sports. But other drugs - antibiotics, insulin, vitamins, and aspirin - are quite acceptable. The basis for these distinctions is not obvious, nor is it self-evident why there should be any restrictions on the use of drugs in sports. Drugs can be used for various purposes: to restore a person with a disease to normal function; to improve function in a healthy person; to relieve pain; and to give pleasure, with no expected effects on performance. Let me emphasize my personal distaste for drugs in sports, particularly performing-enhancing and recreational drugs. As an athlete, I would not use them. As a physician, I would not prescribe them. As a father, I would urge my children to avoid them. As a citizen, I deplore their widespread use. But these are merely preferences and not a sufficient basis for national policy that claims to be based on ethical considerations."
"Banning Drugs in Sports: A Skeptical View," Hastings Center Report, Aug. 1986
Experts
Individuals with MDs, JDs, PhDs, or other relevant advanced degrees, heads of professional sports leagues, and US Congress members with significant involvement in, or related to, performance enhancing drugs and sports. [Note: Experts definition varies by site]
Involvement and Affiliations:
Chair, Ethics and Security Advisory Board, Marshfield Personalized Medicine Research Project, 2004-present
Chair, Hospital Ethics Committee, University of Wisconsin, 1984-present
Professor, Pediatrics and Bioethics, University of Wisconsin, 1973-present
Director and Founder, Medical Ethics Program, University of Wisconsin, 1973-present
Vice Chair, Department of Medical History and Bioethics, University of Wisconsin, 1973-present
Pediatrician, 1964-present
Chair, Health Sciences Institutional Review Board, University of Wisconsin, 1977-2008
Recipient, Patricia Price Browne Award in Bioethics, 2007
Recipient, Lifetime Achievement Award, Protection of Human Subjects, 2006
Head, Child Protection Team, University of Wisconsin, 1973-2006
Recipient, American Academy of Pediatrics William G. Bartholome Award for Excellence in Ethics, 2003
Elected Member, Princeton University Board of Trustees, 1994-1998
Recipient, Nellie Westermann Prize for Research Ethics, 1997
DeCamp Visiting Professor, Bioethics, Princeton University, 1996-1997
Vice Chair, Department of Pediatrics, University of Wisconsin, 1985-1995
Member, President Clinton's Health Care Task Force, 1994
Director, Pediatric Residency Training Program, University of Wisconsin, 1973-1994
Co-Chair, American Society of Human Genetics (ASHG) Committee on Insurance Issues, 1992
Member, ASHG Committee on Population Screening and the Cystic Fibrosis Heterozygote Screening, 1992
Chair, Office of Technology Assessment Committee on Cystic Fibrosis Screening, 1991
"We Should Accept Performance Enhancing Drugs in Competitive Sports," Intelligence Squared (IQ2) US Debate, Jan 16, 2008
Cowritten with J. Peppercorn, et al., "The Dilemma of Data - Safety Monitoring: Provision of Significant New Data to Research Participants," The Lancet, Feb. 9, 2008
"Performance-Enhancing Drugs in Sports," Virtual Mentor: American Medical Association Journal of Ethics, July 2004
"Licensing Boards and the Stigma of Mental Illness," Journal of the American Medical Associations, Feb. 17, 1999
"Waived Consent for Emergency Research," American Journal of Law and Medicine, Jan. 1, 1998
Cowritten with M.F. Fleming, et al., "Informed Consent, Deception, and the Use of Disguised Alcohol Questionnaires," American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse, Sep. 1989
"Ben Johnson: The World's Fastest Scapegoat," New York Times, Oct. 20, 1988
"Stop the Hassle about Drugs," USA Today, Sep. 16-18, 1988
"Banning Drugs in Sports: A Skeptical View," Hastings Center Report, August 1986
"Let 'em Take Steroids," New York Times, Sep. 9, 1983
Other:
Fellow, Program in Law, Medicine and Ethics, Harvard University, 1972-1973